What the Hotel Extractor Actually Found: 527 Evidence Claims Across 10 Hotels
Experiment evidence report: This is a pipeline-results article, not a set of hotel reviews and not a claim of firsthand stays. It exposes the accepted source-backed evidence so the output can be audited directly.
The experiment ran ten hotels—two in each of five property classes—through frozen source acquisition, local quotation-backed extraction, and deterministic class-aware scoring. The tables below include every accepted evidence claim, the kind of evidence the extractor was seeking, the normalized topic, the exact source wording, and the retained source.
Overall result
| Metric | Result |
|---|---|
| Valid hotel lineages | 10 |
| Accepted evidence claims | 527 |
| Property classes | 5, with two hotels in each class |
| Hotels with all six evidence types | 10 of 10 |
| Cloud inference calls | 0 |
| Weighted rubric coverage | 34.7% to 74.0% (mean 61.5%) |
| Price status | Unknown for 10 of 10 |
| Value status | Unknown for 10 of 10 |
| Step 2 model calls / retries | 82 / 30 |
| Step 3 model calls / retries | 60 / 2 |
| Fail-closed scoring demotions | 8 |
All ten scorecards remained not_scored. That is intentional: unknown evidence stayed unknown rather than becoming a zero or an invented fact.
What the extractor looked for
| Evidence type | What it means | Accepted rows |
|---|---|---|
property_fact |
Rooms, pools, parking, Wi-Fi, policies, facilities, design, ownership, and other property-specific facts. | 238 |
guest_like |
What named guests or an explicit review summary said people liked. | 56 |
guest_dislike |
What named guests or an explicit review summary identified as a drawback or limitation. | 54 |
nearby_activity |
Named things to do on the property, resort campus, or nearby. | 64 |
walkability_transport |
Walking distances, driving dependence, shuttles, transit, airport access, and access constraints. | 52 |
dining_outlet |
Exact names of restaurants, cafes, bars, lounges, room service, or a supported self-catering program. | 63 |
The topic column in each hotel table makes the broad type concrete. For example, a property-fact row with topic pool should say something like “one indoor pool on site” if that is what the source actually supports. Missing pool evidence is not converted into “no pool.”
Hotel-level result grid
| Hotel | Class | Claims | Rubric weight covered | Final status | Extraction retries | Scoring demotions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bar Harbor Inn | notable_independent |
72 | 42.0/100.0 (42.0%) | not_scored |
4 | 2 |
| Disney's Coronado Springs Resort | destination_resort |
78 | 68.0/100.0 (68.0%) | not_scored |
5 | 0 |
| Hotel Emma | notable_independent |
43 | 70.0/100.0 (70.0%) | not_scored |
5 | 0 |
| Hampton Inn Tomah | ordinary_chain |
81 | 69.0/100.0 (69.0%) | not_scored |
2 | 1 |
| Captain's House Inn | small_inn_bnb |
39 | 42.0/100.0 (42.0%) | not_scored |
1 | 0 |
| Wigwam Motel | independent_motel |
55 | 69.0/95.0 (72.6%) | not_scored |
1 | 0 |
| Gaylord Opryland Resort & Convention Center | destination_resort |
52 | 74.0/100.0 (74.0%) | not_scored |
5 | 2 |
| Days Inn by Wyndham Hillsdale | ordinary_chain |
38 | 69.0/100.0 (69.0%) | not_scored |
3 | 0 |
| The Inn at Stonington | small_inn_bnb |
51 | 74.0/100.0 (74.0%) | not_scored |
1 | 0 |
| Blue Swallow Motel | independent_motel |
18 | 33.0/95.0 (34.7%) | not_scored |
3 | 3 |
1. Bar Harbor Inn
- Class:
notable_independent - Address: 1 Newport Drive, Bar Harbor, ME 04609, United States
- Accepted claims: 72
- Score status:
not_scored; covered 42.0 of 100.0 applicable rubric weight - Guest source families: aaa, tripadvisor, us-news
- Ledger SHA-256:
25cf751442ee7ee6d277b39e44964203ad60835b7610a581fa563e6ab357bcb7
Criterion result and what it required
| Criterion | Evidence it looked for | Result | Still missing |
|---|---|---|---|
Valuevalue |
broad $–$$$$ price band; verified strengths and inclusions; material guest-review drawbacks or explicit statement that review evidence is sparse; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Priceprice |
broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Locationlocation |
verified property coordinates and identity; property-class profile; nearby useful destination or setting context; deterministic travel distances or times when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Walkabilitywalkability |
frozen pedestrian anchors; pedestrian-route distances rather than straight-line distances; material route barriers or safety limitations; useful daily services when applicable | 4/5 scored | — |
Car-free mobilitycar_free_mobility |
destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness | unknown | frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness |
Guest reputation and consistencyguest_reputation_consistency |
quotation-backed positive guest themes; quotation-backed negative guest themes when present; independent guest-review sources when available; contradictions and source sparsity explicitly disclosed | 4/5 scored | — |
Rooms, comfort, and cleanlinessrooms_comfort_cleanliness |
property-specific room facts; quotation-backed guest likes and dislikes when available; source sparsity and contradictions; renovation or condition freshness when available | unknown | quotation-backed guest likes and dislikes when available; property-specific room facts |
Service and hospitalityservice_hospitality |
quotation-backed guest service evidence when available; source sparsity and contradictions; documented service model appropriate to the property class | unknown | documented service model appropriate to the property class; quotation-backed guest service evidence when available (sufficient breadth) |
Amenities and facilitiesamenities_facilities |
frozen property-class expectation profile; class-appropriate core amenity checklist; property-specific operating evidence; condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material | unknown | property-specific operating evidence; condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material |
On-site diningon_site_dining |
property-class expectation profile; named on-site outlets when offered; meal periods or schedule when material; guest quality or value evidence when available | 3/5 scored | — |
Character, design, and sense of placecharacter_design_sense_of_place |
property-class profile; property-specific identity or design facts; current condition evidence when available; guest atmosphere evidence when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Operational reliability and frictionoperational_reliability_friction |
current class-appropriate operational policies; quotation-backed friction or reliability themes when available; maintenance and facility-availability evidence; contradictions and seasonality when material | 3/5 scored | — |
All 72 accepted evidence claims
| Claim ID | Evidence sought / topic | Supported claim | Exact source wording | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OFFICIAL-1-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The hotel is located on eight landscaped acres along the coast of Frenchman Bay. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel includes a luxury spa. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-003 |
Walkability or transportationaccess |
The hotel offers easy access to the area's prime attractions. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaddress |
The hotel is located at 1 Newport Drive in Bar Harbor, Maine. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationownership |
The property is family owned and operated. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-2-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The hotel is located on the shores of Frenchman Bay with views of the Atlantic Ocean. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
Guests have exclusive access to a heated outdoor infinity pool and jacuzzi. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-003 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Birch Point Buildingbreakfast |
A daily deluxe continental breakfast is served in the Birch Point Building. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-004 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: 1881 shore pathwalking |
Guests can stroll the 1881 shore path from the hotel. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-005 |
Walkability or transportation: Cadillac Mountain entrancedriving_distance |
The hotel is a six-minute drive to the Cadillac Mountain entrance. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Newportrenovation |
The Newport Building was newly renovated in 2022. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-3-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaddress |
The hotel is located at 1 Newport Drive in Bar Harbor, ME 04609. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationcontact |
The hotel can be reached by phone at (844) 814-1668. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationcontact |
The hotel can be reached by email at [email protected]. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationownership |
The property is family owned and operated. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel offers a spa facility. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel offers dining services. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-4-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Mount Desert Reading Roomhistory |
The Mount Desert Reading Room was completed in 1887 with the avowed purpose of promoting literary and social culture. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Mount Desert Reading Roomarchitecture |
The Mount Desert Reading Room was designed by architect William Ralph Emerson. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: steel pierinfrastructure |
A steel pier was constructed in 1902 to allow yachtsmen to access the club from Frenchman Bay. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Mount Desert Reading Roomhistory |
President William Howard Taft received a grand reception at the Mount Desert Reading Room during a three-day visit to Bar Harbor in 1910. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-005 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: restaurantdining |
The club opened a restaurant to the public in 1921. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Bar Harbor Yacht Clubownership |
The Maine Central Railroad purchased the Mount Desert Reading Room in 1923 and leased it to the Bar Harbor Yacht Club. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: U.S. Navyhistory |
During World War II, the U.S. Navy leased the building and used it as an observation headquarters. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-008 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: American Red Crosshistory |
After the 1947 fire, the American Red Cross used the building to assist those who were burned out. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-009 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Hotel Bar Harbordevelopment |
In 1950, a group of townspeople developed the Hotel Bar Harbor to include the Mount Desert Reading Room and a new 40-room wing. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-010 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: motelaccommodations |
A 20-room motel overlooking the Porcupine Islands was added to the Hotel Bar Harbor in 1960. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-011 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Bar Harbor Innownership |
David J. Witham purchased the property in 1987 and changed the name to the Bar Harbor Inn. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-012 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Oceanfront Lodgeaccommodations |
The Oceanfront Lodge building was constructed in 1988, adding 64 guest rooms. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-013 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Newport buildingaccommodations |
The 20-room motel was replaced in 1992 by the two-story Newport building, which added 38 guest rooms. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-014 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Main Inn wingrenovation |
A complete remodel of the Main Inn wing was completed in 1997, adding new guest rooms and Bayview windows. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-015 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Bar Harbor Inn Spaspa |
The building housing the Bar Harbor Inn Spa was constructed in 2006 to provide luxury spa services. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-016 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: infinity edge poolamenities |
An infinity edge pool and two adjacent hot tubs were installed in 2019 to complement the view of Frenchman Bay. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-017 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: pool bardining |
In 2020, the Birch Point building was completed, housing a continental breakfast area, fitness room, and pool bar. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-018 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Bar Harbor Innlocation |
The Bar Harbor Inn is located at 1 Newport Drive, Bar Harbor, ME 04609. |
|
barharborinn.comOFFICIAL-4 |
GUEST-1-001 |
Guest-reported strengthpoolreviewer: JeMoel |
Guests praise the heated infinity pool and hot tubs for their harbor views. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-002 |
Guest-reported strengthbreakfastreviewer: JeMoel |
Guests describe the continental breakfast as exceptional. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-003 |
Walkability or transportationlocationreviewer: JeMoel |
The hotel is located close enough to walk to downtown shops and restaurants. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-004 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Acadiaacadiareviewer: JeMoel |
Guests appreciate the hotel's proximity to Acadia National Park for daily visits. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-005 |
Walkability or transportationlocationreviewer: sarah johnson |
Guests find the hotel location to be a perfect balance of quiet and proximity to downtown. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-006 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: ocean pathocean_pathreviewer: Lap |
Guests enjoy walking the ocean path and viewing boats from their balconies. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-007 |
Guest-reported strengthlocationreviewer: metz1020 |
Guests rate the hotel's location as perfect for their stay. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-008 |
Guest-reported strengthservicereviewer: metz1020 |
Guests praise the staff for being accommodating to young children. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-009 |
Walkability or transportationwalkabilityreviewer: iowagirl |
Guests appreciate the ability to walk to all necessary locations during their stay. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-010 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: lounge, pool bardiningreviewer: iowagirl |
Guests mention dining options including a lounge and pool bar. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-011 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationparking |
The hotel offers free parking for guests. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-012 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationwifi |
The hotel provides free high-speed internet access. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-013 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationfitness |
The hotel features a fitness center with a gym. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-014 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationbeach |
The hotel has a beach area available to guests. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-015 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationplayground |
The hotel includes a children's playground. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-016 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaddress |
The hotel is located at 1 Newport Dr in Bar Harbor. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-017 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationrating |
The hotel is rated 3 out of 5 stars. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-018 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_count |
The hotel has 151 rooms. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-2-001 |
Guest-reported strengthlocationreviewer: source_summary |
Guests liked the property's location. |
|
us-newsGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-002 |
Guest-reported drawbackroom_conditionreviewer: source_summary |
Guests disliked that rooms needed updates. |
|
us-newsGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenitiestime-sensitive |
The property offers a seasonal heated pool and Jacuzzi. |
|
us-newsGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel offers an on-site spa. |
|
us-newsGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationdining |
The hotel provides a complimentary continental breakfast daily. |
|
us-newsGUEST-2 |
GUEST-3-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaddress |
The hotel is located at 1 Newport Dr, Bar Harbor, ME, 04609. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel features an outdoor heated pool, sauna, and hot tub. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationparking |
The hotel offers on-site and valet parking. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationdining |
Breakfast is included in the stay. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-005 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Lounge Full Barbar |
The hotel has a lounge with a full bar. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationservices |
The hotel provides room service. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpet_policy |
Pets are not accepted in the guest rooms. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-008 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocationreviewer: AAA Diamond Inspector Notes |
The hotel is located in the heart of downtown Bar Harbor. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-009 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationgroundsreviewer: AAA Diamond Inspector Notes |
The hotel offers lush gardens and outdoor seating. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-010 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroomsreviewer: AAA Diamond Inspector Notes |
Many rooms have balconies overlooking the harbor. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-011 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationbuilding_structurereviewer: AAA Diamond Inspector Notes |
The hotel building has 3 stories and 151 units. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-012 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: The Verandadining |
The Veranda is a nearby French restaurant. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-013 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Havanadining |
Havana is a nearby restaurant serving Latin American, Seafood, and Contemporary American cuisine. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-014 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Project Social Kitchen & Bardining |
Project Social Kitchen & Bar is a nearby establishment serving small plates. |
|
aaaGUEST-3 |
2. Disney's Coronado Springs Resort
- Class:
destination_resort - Address: 1000 West Buena Vista Drive, Lake Buena Vista, FL 32830, United States
- Accepted claims: 78
- Score status:
not_scored; covered 68.0 of 100.0 applicable rubric weight - Guest source families: independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.com, independent-editorial:wdwmagic.com, tripadvisor, us-news
- Ledger SHA-256:
03f552715aec72189527837c8d490ed208108ec82b6674576703d107ca3ef9c9
Criterion result and what it required
| Criterion | Evidence it looked for | Result | Still missing |
|---|---|---|---|
Valuevalue |
broad $–$$$$ price band; verified strengths and inclusions; material guest-review drawbacks or explicit statement that review evidence is sparse; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Priceprice |
broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Locationlocation |
verified property coordinates and identity; property-class profile; nearby useful destination or setting context; deterministic travel distances or times when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Walkabilitywalkability |
frozen pedestrian anchors; pedestrian-route distances rather than straight-line distances; material route barriers or safety limitations; useful daily services when applicable | unknown | frozen pedestrian anchors; pedestrian-route distances rather than straight-line distances; material route barriers or safety limitations; useful daily services when applicable |
Car-free mobilitycar_free_mobility |
destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness | unknown | frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness |
Guest reputation and consistencyguest_reputation_consistency |
quotation-backed positive guest themes; quotation-backed negative guest themes when present; independent guest-review sources when available; contradictions and source sparsity explicitly disclosed | 3/5 scored | — |
Rooms, comfort, and cleanlinessrooms_comfort_cleanliness |
property-specific room facts; quotation-backed guest likes and dislikes when available; source sparsity and contradictions; renovation or condition freshness when available | 3/5 scored | — |
Service and hospitalityservice_hospitality |
quotation-backed guest service evidence when available; source sparsity and contradictions; documented service model appropriate to the property class | 3/5 scored | — |
Amenities and facilitiesamenities_facilities |
frozen property-class expectation profile; class-appropriate core amenity checklist; property-specific operating evidence; condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material | 4/5 scored | — |
On-site diningon_site_dining |
property-class expectation profile; named on-site outlets when offered; meal periods or schedule when material; guest quality or value evidence when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Character, design, and sense of placecharacter_design_sense_of_place |
property-class profile; property-specific identity or design facts; current condition evidence when available; guest atmosphere evidence when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Operational reliability and frictionoperational_reliability_friction |
current class-appropriate operational policies; quotation-backed friction or reliability themes when available; maintenance and facility-availability evidence; contradictions and seasonality when material | 3/5 scored | — |
All 78 accepted evidence claims
| Claim ID | Evidence sought / topic | Supported claim | Exact source wording | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OFFICIAL-1-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationconstruction_statustime-sensitive |
The resort is currently undergoing construction and refurbishments. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Chronos Clubclub_access |
Guests in Club-access rooms can enter the Chronos Club. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpool_features |
The resort features a pool area built around a 50-foot replica of a Mayan pyramid. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationfitness |
The resort offers 24-hour fitness facilities. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Hey Disney!technology |
The resort provides a voice assistant experience called "Hey Disney!". |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Lightning Laneticketingtime-sensitive |
Guests can purchase Lightning Lane passes up to 7 days in advance of their stay. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The resort is located in the Disney's Animal Kingdom Resort Area. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-2-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationconstruction_statustime-sensitive |
The resort is currently undergoing construction and refurbishments. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-002 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Toledo – Tapas, Steak & Seafoodrestaurant_name |
Toledo is a rooftop restaurant serving Spanish-inspired cuisine. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-003 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Three Bridges Bar & Grill at Villa del Lagorestaurant_name |
Three Bridges Bar & Grill is a lakefront restaurant located at Villa del Lago. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-004 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Rix Sports Bar & Grillrestaurant_name |
Rix Sports Bar & Grill is an upscale sports lounge featuring 31 TVs. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-005 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Dahlia Loungelounge_name |
Dahlia Lounge is a lounge inspired by Spanish surrealism. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-006 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Barcelona Loungelounge_name |
Barcelona Lounge serves espresso drinks and pastries for breakfast. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-007 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Siestas Cantinarestaurant_name |
Siestas Cantina is a poolside dining spot offering cocktails and food. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-008 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Maya Grillrestaurant_name |
Maya Grill serves traditional Mexican fare. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-009 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Café Rixcafe_name |
Café Rix offers smoothies, coffee, pastries, and gelato. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-010 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: El Mercado de Coronadorestaurant_name |
El Mercado de Coronado provides Grab & Go fare for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-011 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Laguna Barbar_name |
Laguna Bar is a lakeside tequila and mezcal bar. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-012 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaddress |
The hotel is located at 1001 West Buena Vista Drive in Lake Buena Vista, Florida. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-013 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationhotel_category |
The hotel is classified as a Moderate Resort. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-014 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationresort_area |
The hotel is situated in Disney's Animal Kingdom Resort Area. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-015 |
Walkability or transportationtransportation |
Motorcoach transportation is available for guests. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-3-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Lost City of Cibola Poolpool_features |
The Dig Site pool complex features a 50-foot pyramid centerpiece. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Dig Sitewaterslide |
The Dig Site includes a 123-foot-long waterslide with a spitting Jaguar spirit animal. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Dig Sitehot_tub |
The Dig Site has the largest hot tub on Walt Disney World Resort property, seating 22 people. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-004 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Siesta’s pool barpool_bar |
Siesta’s pool bar is located at the Dig Site. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationleisure_pools |
Three leisure pools are located at the Casitas, Ranchos, and Cabanas settlements. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
Complimentary towels are provided at all pools. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpool_hourstime-sensitive |
Pool hours and lifeguard availability vary by pool and are subject to change. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-4-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationconstruction_statustime-sensitive |
The resort is currently undergoing construction and refurbishments. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-002 |
Walkability or transportationtransportation |
Complimentary bus transportation is available to and from all Disney theme parks and water parks. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Hey Disney!technology_services |
A voice assistant named "Hey Disney!" is available to order items and answer park questions. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-004 |
Walkability or transportation: Minnie Vantransportation |
Minnie Van service, connected by Lyft, is available for travel within Walt Disney World Resort for an additional charge. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationfinancial_services |
A 24-hour ATM is located to the right of the Front Desk area. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Business Centerbusiness_facilities |
The Business Center is located inside the Disney’s Coronado Springs Resort Convention Center. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Convention Centermeeting_space |
The Convention Center features 220,000 square feet of meeting space, including 2 ballrooms, an exhibit hall, and 45 breakout rooms. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-008 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationhousekeeping |
Housekeeping service is provided every other day for the duration of the stay. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-009 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlaundry |
A 24-hour self-service laundry room is located adjacent to each of the 3 quiet village pools. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-010 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationmail_services |
Guests can send pre-stamped postcards and letters from the Front Desk. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-011 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Club Level Conciergeconcierge |
The Club Level Concierge offers services such as purchasing tickets and making dining reservations. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-012 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationclub_level_benefits |
Guests staying in Club-level rooms and suites are eligible for personalized vacation-planning support. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-013 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaddress |
The hotel is located at 1001 West Buena Vista Drive in Lake Buena Vista, Florida. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
OFFICIAL-4-014 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationhotel_category |
The hotel is categorized as a Moderate Resort in Disney's Animal Kingdom Resort Area. |
|
disneyworld.disney.go.comOFFICIAL-4 |
GUEST-1-001 |
Guest-reported strengthroom_qualityreviewer: source_summary |
Guests appreciate the spacious and comfortable rooms, though some report noise and housekeeping issues. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-002 |
Guest-reported drawbackwalkabilityreviewer: source_summary |
Guests warn of long walks required to move around the property due to its large size. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-003 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Dig Site poolpoolreviewer: Jonathan J |
The Dig Site pool with a faux-Mayan pyramid is a highlight of the resort. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-004 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Dahlia and Toledorestaurantsreviewer: Jonathan J |
The resort features rooftop restaurants named Dahlia and Toledo. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-005 |
Walkability or transportationtransportationreviewer: Jonathan J |
The resort is bus-only for transportation to parks, lacking monorails or Skyliners. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-006 |
Guest-reported drawbackservicereviewer: Mark V |
Guests report difficulty finding staff assistance after 10 PM. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenitiesreviewer: ELKW |
The resort offers free parking and early entry to the parks. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-2-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationresort_classification |
The resort is described as Walt Disney World's biggest convention hotel. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-002 |
Walkability or transportationtransportation_access |
Guests must rely on bus transportation or their own vehicles as the resort is not adjacent to theme parks. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-003 |
Walkability or transportationtransportation_access |
There is no boat or monorail transportation from the resort to theme parks or Disney Springs. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-004 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Dig Site poolpool_amenities |
The Dig Site pool area features a 123-foot water slide, an arcade, and the largest hot tub at Walt Disney World. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-005 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: El Mercado de Coronadodining_options |
El Mercado de Coronado is a counter service restaurant at the resort. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-006 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Three Bridges Bar & Grilldining_options |
Three Bridges Bar & Grill is an over-the-water dining option with views of fireworks at Epcot and Disney's Hollywood Studios. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-007 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Toledo — Tapas, Steak & Seafooddining_options |
Toledo — Tapas, Steak & Seafood is a high-end dining location inside Gran Destino Tower. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-008 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Dahlia Loungedining_options |
Dahlia Lounge is located on the top floor of Gran Destino Tower. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-009 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Barcelona Loungedining_options |
Barcelona Lounge is located in the lobby of Gran Destino Tower. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-010 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
Guest rooms feature in-room Keurig machines. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-011 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationresort_layout |
The resort is spread out, with Lago Dorado, a 22-acre lake, in the center. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-012 |
Guest-reported strengthguest_experiencereviewer: Jenn |
Guest Jenn enjoyed the pool, Three Bridges, and Dahlia Lounge during her stay. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-013 |
Guest-reported strengthguest_experiencereviewer: D. Fas |
Guest D. Fas found the pool area awesome and the restaurants great. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-014 |
Guest-reported drawbacktransportation_accessreviewer: Tracey |
Guest Tracey found the walk from the drop-off point to the rooms very long when using Uber. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-015 |
Guest-reported strengthguest_experiencereviewer: TGambler |
Guest TGambler found the rooms clean and spacious and the restaurants above expectation. |
|
independent-editorial:disneytouristblog.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-3-001 |
Guest-reported drawbacktransportationreviewer: source_summary |
Guests were disappointed by the bus service efficiency and frequency. |
|
us-newsGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-002 |
Guest-reported strengthamenitiesreviewer: source_summary |
Guests were impressed by the variety of on-site amenities including a playground, arcade, spa, and fitness center. |
|
us-newsGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-003 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Dig Sitepool |
The Dig Site is a Mayan-themed pool complex featuring a 50-foot pyramid and a 123-foot-long waterslide. |
|
us-newsGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-004 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Dig Siteevening_activitiestime-sensitive |
Campfire activities are held at the Dig Site each evening. |
|
us-newsGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-005 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Gran Destino Lawnentertainmenttime-sensitive |
Disney film screenings are held on the Gran Destino Lawn nightly. |
|
us-newsGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
Guest rooms are equipped with coffee makers, minifridges, in-room safes, and free Wi-Fi access. |
|
us-newsGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-007 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: club-level loungeclub_access |
Club Access rooms and suites provide access to a club-level lounge. |
|
us-newsGUEST-3 |
GUEST-4-001 |
Guest-reported strengthroom_qualityreviewer: Alexa Y |
Guests in the Cabanas section reported that the rooms felt private and had amazing views. |
|
independent-editorial:wdwmagic.comGUEST-4 |
GUEST-4-002 |
Guest-reported drawbackroom_conditionreviewer: PenPan |
A guest staying in the Ranchos section described the room as worn out and depressing. |
|
independent-editorial:wdwmagic.comGUEST-4 |
GUEST-4-003 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Pepper Marketdiningreviewer: J Bishop |
Pepper Market is a main restaurant at the resort where guests have expressed dissatisfaction with dining plans and prices. |
|
independent-editorial:wdwmagic.comGUEST-4 |
GUEST-4-004 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Dig poolpool_accessreviewer: SueJer |
Guests can walk to the Dig pool from the Cabanas section. |
|
independent-editorial:wdwmagic.comGUEST-4 |
GUEST-4-005 |
Walkability or transportationmobilityreviewer: emcclay |
The resort is large, requiring significant walking, and guests suggest renting a scooter if walking is a problem. |
|
independent-editorial:wdwmagic.comGUEST-4 |
GUEST-4-006 |
Walkability or transportationtransportationreviewer: bhg469 |
Guests noted that the buses at the resort work better than at any other Disney resort. |
|
independent-editorial:wdwmagic.comGUEST-4 |
3. Hotel Emma
- Class:
notable_independent - Address: 136 East Grayson Street, San Antonio, TX 78215, United States
- Accepted claims: 43
- Score status:
not_scored; covered 70.0 of 100.0 applicable rubric weight - Guest source families: conde-nast-traveler, independent-editorial:tablethotels.com, tripadvisor
- Ledger SHA-256:
d03e9c410b1a2f400c0b7eb312156721cef79239f38803e37385d01a4128dde6
Criterion result and what it required
| Criterion | Evidence it looked for | Result | Still missing |
|---|---|---|---|
Valuevalue |
broad $–$$$$ price band; verified strengths and inclusions; material guest-review drawbacks or explicit statement that review evidence is sparse; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Priceprice |
broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Locationlocation |
verified property coordinates and identity; property-class profile; nearby useful destination or setting context; deterministic travel distances or times when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Walkabilitywalkability |
frozen pedestrian anchors; pedestrian-route distances rather than straight-line distances; material route barriers or safety limitations; useful daily services when applicable | 3/5 scored | — |
Car-free mobilitycar_free_mobility |
destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness | unknown | frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness |
Guest reputation and consistencyguest_reputation_consistency |
quotation-backed positive guest themes; quotation-backed negative guest themes when present; independent guest-review sources when available; contradictions and source sparsity explicitly disclosed | 3/5 scored | — |
Rooms, comfort, and cleanlinessrooms_comfort_cleanliness |
property-specific room facts; quotation-backed guest likes and dislikes when available; source sparsity and contradictions; renovation or condition freshness when available | 3/5 scored | — |
Service and hospitalityservice_hospitality |
quotation-backed guest service evidence when available; source sparsity and contradictions; documented service model appropriate to the property class | 4/5 scored | — |
Amenities and facilitiesamenities_facilities |
frozen property-class expectation profile; class-appropriate core amenity checklist; property-specific operating evidence; condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material | 4/5 scored | — |
On-site diningon_site_dining |
property-class expectation profile; named on-site outlets when offered; meal periods or schedule when material; guest quality or value evidence when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Character, design, and sense of placecharacter_design_sense_of_place |
property-class profile; property-specific identity or design facts; current condition evidence when available; guest atmosphere evidence when available | 5/5 scored | — |
Operational reliability and frictionoperational_reliability_friction |
current class-appropriate operational policies; quotation-backed friction or reliability themes when available; maintenance and facility-availability evidence; contradictions and seasonality when material | unknown | current class-appropriate operational policies; maintenance and facility-availability evidence; quotation-backed friction or reliability themes when available |
All 43 accepted evidence claims
| Claim ID | Evidence sought / topic | Supported claim | Exact source wording | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OFFICIAL-1-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationhotel_overview |
Hotel Emma is a 146-room riverfront hotel located in San Antonio's Historic Pearl District. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-002 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Pullman Marketnearby_dining |
Pullman Market is a culinary destination located a short walk from the hotel. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-003 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Stable Hallnearby_entertainment |
Stable Hall is a live entertainment venue located a four-minute stroll from the hotel. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationawardstime-sensitive |
The hotel is the only Michelin Two Key hotel in San Antonio. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-2-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationhotel_size_location |
Hotel Emma is a 146-room hotel located in San Antonio. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationrooftop_pool |
The hotel features a rooftop pool with cabanas and poolside refreshments. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationfitness_center |
The hotel has a third-floor fitness center with river views. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlibrary |
The hotel houses a 3,700-volume library acquired from Sherry Kafka Wagner. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Curiogift_shop |
Curio is a gift shop offering curated items like postcards and robes. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-006 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Lardergrocery_store |
Larder is a fine groceries and prepared foods outlet. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaddress |
The hotel is located at 136 E. Grayson Street in San Antonio. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-3-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
The Garret room features a clawfoot tub with a view of the Pearl Plaza. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_features |
Terrace rooms include an 86 square foot private terrace with a fireplace and mesquite bench. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationbathroom_amenities |
Bathrooms are equipped with handmade Spanish porcelain tile and Frette towels. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationarrival_amenity |
Guests receive a La Babia Margarita upon arrival in their room. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaddress |
The hotel is located at 136 E. Grayson Street in San Antonio, Texas. |
|
thehotelemma.comOFFICIAL-3 |
GUEST-1-001 |
Guest-reported strengthlocationreviewer: Samantha S |
Guests praise the hotel's location in the heart of the Pearl district. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-002 |
Guest-reported strength: Libraryamenitiesreviewer: Peter N |
Guests appreciate the guest-only library and its curated collection. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-003 |
Guest-reported drawbackroom_amenitiesreviewer: sola123 |
Guests note the absence of in-room coffee and tea makers as a shortcoming. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-004 |
Walkability or transportationaccessibility |
The hotel area is graded as somewhat walkable with a score of 80 out of 100. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationhistory |
The hotel is a repurposed 19th-century brewhouse. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-2-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlibraryreviewer: DIANA OATES |
The hotel features a library with a 3,700-volume collection. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Plaza Suiteroom_viewreviewer: DIANA OATES |
The Plaza Suite offers floor-to-ceiling windows with views of Pearl Plaza. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Dos Carolinasroom_amenitiesreviewer: DIANA OATES |
Guests receive custom-made Guayabera robes from Dos Carolinas. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Ice Boxroom_amenitiesreviewer: DIANA OATES |
The Ice Box provides local beer, farmers market provisions, and margarita ingredients. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-005 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Merit Roasting Co.coffee_servicereviewer: DIANA OATES |
Merit Roasting Co. provides coffee service throughout the hotel. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-006 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Supperrestaurantreviewer: DIANA OATES |
Supper is a restaurant located within the hotel suitable for dinner or brunch. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-007 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Larderrestaurantreviewer: DIANA OATES |
Larder is a restaurant located within the hotel suitable for lunch. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-008 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Sternewirthbarreviewer: DIANA OATES |
Sternewirth is a bar located within the hotel for cocktails. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-009 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpoolreviewer: DIANA OATES |
The hotel has a rooftop pool with cabanas. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-010 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Hiatus Spaspareviewer: DIANA OATES |
Hiatus Spa offers massages and facials, including in-room service. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-011 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationwelcome_drinkreviewer: DIANA OATES |
The hotel offers complimentary check-in margaritas. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-012 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationconnectivityreviewer: DIANA OATES |
The hotel features free wifi. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-013 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_count |
The hotel has 146 rooms. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-014 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaddress |
The hotel is located at 136 E Grayson St., San Antonio, Texas. |
|
conde-nast-travelerGUEST-2 |
GUEST-3-001 |
Guest-reported strengthamenitiesreviewer: Eric |
Guest Eric praised the service, environment, bar, and pool. |
|
independent-editorial:tablethotels.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-002 |
Guest-reported drawbackdining_fitnessreviewer: Eric |
Guest Eric advised against visiting the food or gym. |
|
independent-editorial:tablethotels.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-003 |
Walkability or transportation: river walkwalking_distancereviewer: Eric |
Guest Eric noted the walk from the river walk along the river was 2.5 miles. |
|
independent-editorial:tablethotels.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-004 |
Guest-reported strength: Libraryinterior_designreviewer: Anna |
Guest Anna described the library as gorgeous. |
|
independent-editorial:tablethotels.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-005 |
Guest-reported strengthservicereviewer: Paul |
Guest Paul praised the concierge service as the best. |
|
independent-editorial:tablethotels.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-006 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Pearl districtdining_optionsreviewer: Paul |
Guest Paul mentioned a dozen high-caliber restaurants in walking distance in the Pearl district. |
|
independent-editorial:tablethotels.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The hotel is located at 136 E. Grayson St., San Antonio, TX, USA. |
|
independent-editorial:tablethotels.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-008 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationparking_costtime-sensitive |
Valet parking is available for $45 per day. |
|
independent-editorial:tablethotels.comGUEST-3 |
4. Hampton Inn Tomah
- Class:
ordinary_chain - Address: 219 Buan Street, Tomah, WI 54660, United States
- Accepted claims: 81
- Score status:
not_scored; covered 69.0 of 100.0 applicable rubric weight - Guest source families: expedia-group, kayak, tripadvisor
- Ledger SHA-256:
29d1a5facb7209188e95ef67f5d26c410dacbfd987099779be013c8db6c48d2f
Criterion result and what it required
| Criterion | Evidence it looked for | Result | Still missing |
|---|---|---|---|
Valuevalue |
broad $–$$$$ price band; verified strengths and inclusions; material guest-review drawbacks or explicit statement that review evidence is sparse; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language |
Priceprice |
broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language |
Locationlocation |
verified property coordinates and identity; property-class profile; nearby useful destination or setting context; deterministic travel distances or times when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Walkabilitywalkability |
frozen pedestrian anchors; pedestrian-route distances rather than straight-line distances; material route barriers or safety limitations; useful daily services when applicable | 1/5 scored | — |
Car-free mobilitycar_free_mobility |
destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness | unknown | frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness |
Guest reputation and consistencyguest_reputation_consistency |
quotation-backed positive guest themes; quotation-backed negative guest themes when present; independent guest-review sources when available; contradictions and source sparsity explicitly disclosed | 3/5 scored | — |
Rooms, comfort, and cleanlinessrooms_comfort_cleanliness |
property-specific room facts; quotation-backed guest likes and dislikes when available; source sparsity and contradictions; renovation or condition freshness when available | 3/5 scored | — |
Service and hospitalityservice_hospitality |
quotation-backed guest service evidence when available; source sparsity and contradictions; documented service model appropriate to the property class | 3/5 scored | — |
Amenities and facilitiesamenities_facilities |
frozen property-class expectation profile; class-appropriate core amenity checklist; property-specific operating evidence; condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material | 4/5 scored | — |
On-site diningon_site_dining |
property-class expectation profile; named on-site outlets when offered; meal periods or schedule when material; guest quality or value evidence when available | 3/5 scored | — |
Character, design, and sense of placecharacter_design_sense_of_place |
property-class profile; property-specific identity or design facts; current condition evidence when available; guest atmosphere evidence when available | unknown | property-specific identity or design facts; guest atmosphere evidence |
Operational reliability and frictionoperational_reliability_friction |
current class-appropriate operational policies; quotation-backed friction or reliability themes when available; maintenance and facility-availability evidence; contradictions and seasonality when material | 3/5 scored | — |
All 81 accepted evidence claims
| Claim ID | Evidence sought / topic | Supported claim | Exact source wording | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OFFICIAL-1-001 |
Walkability or transportation: Fort McCoy Army Basedriving_distance |
Fort McCoy Army Base and Volk Field Air National Guard Base are within 20 minutes' drive of the hotel. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-002 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Tomah Sparta Speedwaynearby_attraction |
Tomah Sparta Speedway is located five minutes from the hotel. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-003 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Wisconsin Cranberry Discovery Centernearby_attraction |
Wisconsin Cranberry Discovery Center is 15 minutes away from the hotel. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel offers free hot breakfast and free WiFi. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationrecreation |
The hotel features an indoor pool and a fitness center. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationparking |
The hotel provides self-parking that is on-site and complimentary. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-007 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Whitetail Crossing Casinonearby_attraction |
Whitetail Crossing Casino is located 4 miles from the hotel. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-2-001 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Free hot breakfastbreakfast |
The hotel offers a free hot breakfast. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationrecreation |
The hotel features an indoor pool. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationfitness |
The hotel has a fitness center. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationbusiness |
The hotel provides a business center. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationevents |
The hotel offers meeting rooms. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationtransport |
EV charging is available for guests. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationparking |
Parking is free for guests. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-008 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationconnectivity |
WiFi is provided free of charge. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-009 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaccess |
The hotel offers digital key access. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-010 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationloyalty |
The hotel participates in the Hilton Honors program. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-011 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationrooms |
Connecting rooms are available. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-012 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationentertainment |
Rooms include streaming entertainment. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-013 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaccessibility |
The hotel has accessible features. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-014 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpolicies |
Check-in time is 3 pm. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-015 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpolicies |
Check-out time is 11 am. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-016 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationparking |
Self-parking is complimentary. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-017 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationparking |
Valet parking is not available. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-018 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationtransport |
EV charging is available on-site. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-3-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaddress |
The hotel is located at 219 Buan Street in Tomah, Wisconsin. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationrenovation |
The hotel has been recently renovated. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationbreakfast |
Guests receive a free hot breakfast. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationconnectivity |
The hotel provides free WiFi. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationparking |
The hotel offers free parking. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel features an indoor pool. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel has a fitness center. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-008 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel includes a business center. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-009 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpets |
The hotel offers pet-friendly rooms. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-010 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_configurationtime-sensitive |
The hotel offers connecting rooms subject to availability. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-011 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpricingtime-sensitive |
Standard queen rooms start at $139 per night. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-012 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpricingtime-sensitive |
Standard king rooms start at $148 per night. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-013 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
Guest rooms include a workspace. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-014 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
Guest rooms include a microwave. |
|
www.hilton.comOFFICIAL-3 |
GUEST-1-001 |
Guest-reported strengthroom_qualityreviewer: Lucky |
Guests praised the hotel for having clean rooms and a quiet atmosphere. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-002 |
Guest-reported drawbackbreakfastreviewer: Lucky |
Guests noted that the hot breakfast items could have been served warmer. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-003 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Elroy-Sparta Bike Trailbiking |
The hotel is located near the Elroy-Sparta Bike Trail. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-004 |
Walkability or transportationhighway_accessreviewer: Amber m |
The hotel is situated close to the interstate highway. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-005 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Culver'srestaurant |
Culver's is a nearby restaurant located within 0.75 miles of the hotel. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel offers free high-speed internet access. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-2-001 |
Guest-reported strengthstaff_servicereviewer: source_summary |
Guests praised the staff for being friendly and helpful. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-002 |
Guest-reported drawbackbed_comfortreviewer: source_summary |
Guests noted that the mattress was too soft. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-003 |
Guest-reported drawbackpricingtime-sensitive; reviewer: source_summary |
Guests complained about high nightly rates during the tractor pull weekend. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-004 |
Guest-reported drawbackstaff_servicereviewer: source_summary |
Guests reported that the desk clerk was not friendly upon arrival. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-005 |
Guest-reported strengthlocation_accessreviewer: Elizabeth |
Guests found the location easily accessible from the interstate. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-006 |
Guest-reported drawbackbed_comfortreviewer: Kayla |
Guests found the bed to be hard and uncomfortable. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-007 |
Guest-reported drawbackroom_amenitiesreviewer: Judy |
Guests complained that the alarm clock time was incorrect and could not be changed. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-008 |
Guest-reported drawbackdining_qualityreviewer: Kim |
Guests noted that the quality of the breakfast had declined. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-009 |
Guest-reported drawbackamenity_locationreviewer: Kim |
Guests reported that the ice machine was located far from other areas. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-010 |
Guest-reported drawbackdining_availabilityreviewer: Anton |
Guests reported that the breakfast bar sausage and eggs were empty. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-011 |
Walkability or transportationtransportationreviewer: David |
Guests noted that there are no Uber, taxi, or shuttle services available from the area. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-012 |
Guest-reported strengthroom_comfortreviewer: Susan |
Guests praised the comfortable beds and quiet air conditioning. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-013 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The hotel is located midway between Milwaukee and the Twin Cities. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-014 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Lake Tomahoutdoor_activities |
Guests can catch a sunset over Lake Tomah and go fishing or boating. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-015 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Elroy-Sparta Bike Trailoutdoor_activities |
Guests can pedal along the Elroy-Sparta Bike Trail. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-016 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Wisconsin Cranberry Discovery Centertourist_attractions |
Guests can visit the Wisconsin Cranberry Discovery Center. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-017 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel offers an indoor pool. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-018 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel offers free Wi-Fi. |
|
kayakGUEST-2 |
GUEST-3-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel provides a free breakfast buffet. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel features a hot tub for relaxation. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationconnectivity |
Guests have access to free in-room WiFi. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-004 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: snack bar/delidining |
The hotel includes a business center and a snack bar/deli. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel has an indoor pool. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-006 |
Walkability or transportationparking |
Free self parking is available on site. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-007 |
Guest-reported strengthservicereviewer: source_summary |
Guest reviews praise the helpful staff. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-008 |
Walkability or transportationlocation |
The hotel is located near a train station. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-009 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Mill Bluff State Parkattractions |
Mill Bluff State Park is a nearby natural attraction. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-010 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Butts Parkattractions |
Butts Park is a nearby natural attraction. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-011 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Area Community Theatreattractions |
Area Community Theatre is a cultural highlight nearby. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-012 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Deke Slayton Memorial Space and Bicycle Museumattractions |
Deke Slayton Memorial Space and Bicycle Museum is a cultural highlight nearby. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-013 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Hiawatha Golf Clubattractions |
Hiawatha Golf Club is a 2-minute drive from the hotel. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-014 |
Walkability or transportation: Tomah Stationtransportation |
Tomah Station is a 4-minute drive from the hotel. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-015 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: McDonald'sdining |
McDonald's is an 11-minute walk from the hotel. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-016 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Taco Belldining |
Taco Bell is a 9-minute walk from the hotel. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-017 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: The Break Room Sports Bar & Grilldining |
The Break Room Sports Bar & Grill is a 6-minute drive from the hotel. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-018 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Murray’s on Maindining |
Murray’s on Main is a 5-minute drive from the hotel. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-3 |
5. Captain's House Inn
- Class:
small_inn_bnb - Address: 369 Old Harbor Road, Chatham, MA 02633, United States
- Accepted claims: 39
- Score status:
not_scored; covered 42.0 of 100.0 applicable rubric weight - Guest source families: expedia-group, tripadvisor
- Ledger SHA-256:
810a31a71bd07185aec3bc78e294265f1a2a8192db624275b997675d79f4ffdb
Criterion result and what it required
| Criterion | Evidence it looked for | Result | Still missing |
|---|---|---|---|
Valuevalue |
broad $–$$$$ price band; verified strengths and inclusions; material guest-review drawbacks or explicit statement that review evidence is sparse; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Priceprice |
broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Locationlocation |
verified property coordinates and identity; property-class profile; nearby useful destination or setting context; deterministic travel distances or times when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Walkabilitywalkability |
frozen pedestrian anchors; pedestrian-route distances rather than straight-line distances; material route barriers or safety limitations; useful daily services when applicable | 2/5 scored | — |
Car-free mobilitycar_free_mobility |
destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness | unknown | destinations served by scheduled shared transport; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness |
Guest reputation and consistencyguest_reputation_consistency |
quotation-backed positive guest themes; quotation-backed negative guest themes when present; independent guest-review sources when available; contradictions and source sparsity explicitly disclosed | 4/5 scored | — |
Rooms, comfort, and cleanlinessrooms_comfort_cleanliness |
property-specific room facts; quotation-backed guest likes and dislikes when available; source sparsity and contradictions; renovation or condition freshness when available | unknown | quotation-backed guest likes and dislikes when available; source sparsity and contradictions; renovation or condition freshness when available |
Service and hospitalityservice_hospitality |
quotation-backed guest service evidence when available; source sparsity and contradictions; documented service model appropriate to the property class | unknown | documented service model appropriate to the property class; source sparsity and contradictions |
Amenities and facilitiesamenities_facilities |
frozen property-class expectation profile; class-appropriate core amenity checklist; property-specific operating evidence; condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material | unknown | property-specific operating evidence; condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material |
On-site diningon_site_dining |
property-class expectation profile; named on-site outlets when offered; meal periods or schedule when material; guest quality or value evidence when available | 3/5 scored | — |
Character, design, and sense of placecharacter_design_sense_of_place |
property-class profile; property-specific identity or design facts; current condition evidence when available; guest atmosphere evidence when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Operational reliability and frictionoperational_reliability_friction |
current class-appropriate operational policies; quotation-backed friction or reliability themes when available; maintenance and facility-availability evidence; contradictions and seasonality when material | 3/5 scored | — |
All 39 accepted evidence claims
| Claim ID | Evidence sought / topic | Supported claim | Exact source wording | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OFFICIAL-1-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The inn is located on two landscaped acres of English gardens in Chatham, Massachusetts. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-002 |
Guest-reported strengthreputationreviewer: source_summary |
Reviewers regard the inn as perhaps Cape Cod's finest bed and breakfast. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_count |
The inn has sixteen guest rooms and suites. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
All guest rooms and suites feature fireplaces. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
All guest rooms and suites feature SmartTVs. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
All guest rooms and suites feature complimentary wifi. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
All guest rooms and suites feature private bathrooms. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-008 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
All guest rooms and suites feature air conditioning. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-009 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
Some accommodations feature whirlpool tubs. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-010 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Provincetown, Nantucket, and Martha’s Vineyardlocation |
The inn is centrally located in Chatham, making it a base for day trips to Provincetown, Nantucket, and Martha's Vineyard. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-011 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Chatham’s quaint Main Streetlocal_shopping |
Guests can stroll along Chatham's Main Street, which is lined with boutiques, galleries, and eateries. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-012 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: English gardensgrounds |
Guests can lounge on Adirondack chairs among the inn's English gardens. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-013 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaffiliations |
The inn is a member of Select Registry and Distinctive Inns of New England. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-014 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationavailability |
The property is open year-round. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-015 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpolicy |
The inn is an adult-only property. |
|
www.captainshouseinn.comOFFICIAL-1 |
GUEST-1-001 |
Guest-reported strengthbreakfast_qualityreviewer: Laura F |
Guests praised the exceptional breakfast provided by staff member Rachel. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-002 |
Walkability or transportationlocation_conveniencereviewer: Shirley T |
The property is located close to the town center, shops, and restaurants. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel offers free parking and free high-speed internet. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-004 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Chatham Pier Fish Marketnearby_dining |
Chatham Pier Fish Market is a nearby attraction and restaurant located 8 minutes away. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationproperty_type |
The hotel is an adults-only, four-diamond sea captain's estate on two acres. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-006 |
Guest-reported drawbackroom_accessibilityreviewer: LawrenceSawyer |
Guests noted that the stairs to the Hideaway Suite are steep and the ceiling is low. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-2-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationbreakfast |
The property offers a free full breakfast. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationreception |
The property provides a free daily manager's reception. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationterrace |
The property features a terrace. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
Guests have access to a garden and a library. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationwifi |
The property offers free in-room WiFi. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The property is located near the beach in Chatham. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-007 |
Walkability or transportation: Cape Cod Beacheswalking_distance |
Cape Cod Beaches is an 8-minute walk from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-008 |
Walkability or transportation: Chatham Fish Pierwalking_distance |
Chatham Fish Pier is an 11-minute walk from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-009 |
Walkability or transportation: Chatham Railroad Museumwalking_distance |
Chatham Railroad Museum is a 14-minute walk from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-010 |
Walkability or transportation: Chatham Drama Guildwalking_distance |
Chatham Drama Guild is a 16-minute walk from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-011 |
Walkability or transportation: Chatham Seaside Linkswalking_distance |
Chatham Seaside Links is a 19-minute walk from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-012 |
Walkability or transportation: Hyannis Transportation Centerdriving_distance |
Hyannis Transportation Center is a 28-minute drive from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-013 |
Walkability or transportation: Logan International Airport (BOS)driving_distance |
Logan International Airport is a 111-minute drive from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-014 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Chatham Squirerestaurant |
Chatham Squire is a 2-minute drive from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-015 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Red River Bbqrestaurant |
Red River Bbq is a 9-minute drive from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-016 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Wychmere Harbor Clubrestaurant |
Wychmere Harbor Club is a 12-minute drive from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-017 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationparking |
The property offers free self parking on site. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-018 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_features |
Guest rooms include fireplaces and premium bedding. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
6. Wigwam Motel
- Class:
independent_motel - Address: 811 West Hopi Drive, Holbrook, AZ 86025, United States
- Accepted claims: 55
- Score status:
not_scored; covered 69.0 of 95.0 applicable rubric weight - Guest source families: independent-editorial:paulagaston.com, independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.com, tripadvisor
- Ledger SHA-256:
600714a9d98f48a19c40afe14f112ba24eba5ef0650c35278256c534e57eb51a
Criterion result and what it required
| Criterion | Evidence it looked for | Result | Still missing |
|---|---|---|---|
Valuevalue |
broad $–$$$$ price band; verified strengths and inclusions; material guest-review drawbacks or explicit statement that review evidence is sparse; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Priceprice |
broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Locationlocation |
verified property coordinates and identity; property-class profile; nearby useful destination or setting context; deterministic travel distances or times when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Walkabilitywalkability |
frozen pedestrian anchors; pedestrian-route distances rather than straight-line distances; material route barriers or safety limitations; useful daily services when applicable | 1/5 scored | — |
Car-free mobilitycar_free_mobility |
destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness | unknown | destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness |
Guest reputation and consistencyguest_reputation_consistency |
quotation-backed positive guest themes; quotation-backed negative guest themes when present; independent guest-review sources when available; contradictions and source sparsity explicitly disclosed | 3/5 scored | — |
Rooms, comfort, and cleanlinessrooms_comfort_cleanliness |
property-specific room facts; quotation-backed guest likes and dislikes when available; source sparsity and contradictions; renovation or condition freshness when available | 3/5 scored | — |
Service and hospitalityservice_hospitality |
quotation-backed guest service evidence when available; source sparsity and contradictions; documented service model appropriate to the property class | 3/5 scored | — |
Amenities and facilitiesamenities_facilities |
frozen property-class expectation profile; class-appropriate core amenity checklist; property-specific operating evidence; condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material | 2/5 scored | — |
On-site diningon_site_dining |
property-class expectation profile; named on-site outlets when offered; meal periods or schedule when material; guest quality or value evidence when available | not_applicable | — |
Character, design, and sense of placecharacter_design_sense_of_place |
property-class profile; property-specific identity or design facts; current condition evidence when available; guest atmosphere evidence when available | 5/5 scored | — |
Operational reliability and frictionoperational_reliability_friction |
current class-appropriate operational policies; quotation-backed friction or reliability themes when available; maintenance and facility-availability evidence; contradictions and seasonality when material | 3/5 scored | — |
All 55 accepted evidence claims
| Claim ID | Evidence sought / topic | Supported claim | Exact source wording | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OFFICIAL-1-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The motel is located on Old Route 66 in Holbrook, Arizona. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationhistory |
The property was built by Chester Evert Lewis. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationmanagement |
The motel is currently operated by the family of the original builder. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-004 |
Guest-reported strengthnostalgiareviewer: source_summary |
Guests appreciate the nostalgic connection to Route 66 road trips from their youth. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-005 |
Guest-reported strengthunique_accommodationreviewer: source_summary |
Guests enjoy the unique setting of sleeping in a wigwam. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-006 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: classic car displayattraction |
A classic car display is located in the parking lot outside the wigwam units. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_features |
The wigwam rooms feature original furnishings. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-008 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_types |
The property offers modern apartments for larger groups or extended stays. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-009 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Petrified Forestattraction |
Petrified Forest is listed as a recommended activity or stop. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-010 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Hidden Coveattraction |
Hidden Cove is listed as a recommended activity or stop. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-011 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Meteor Craterattraction |
Meteor Crater is listed as a recommended activity or stop. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-012 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Old Route 66attraction |
Old Route 66 is listed as a recommended activity or stop. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-013 |
Guest-reported strengthreviewstime-sensitive; reviewer: source_summary |
The motel has an average rating of 5 out of 5 based on over 1,100 Google reviews. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-014 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpoliciestime-sensitive |
The hotel has a 24-hour cancellation policy. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-015 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationmedia |
The hotel gallery includes photos dating back to the 1950s. |
|
sleepinawigwam.comOFFICIAL-1 |
GUEST-1-001 |
Guest-reported strengthamenitiesreviewer: Kat5409 |
Guests praised the restored property, comfortable rooms, pool, and early morning coffee in the office. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-002 |
Guest-reported strengthatmospherereviewer: Scott Dorsey |
Guests enjoyed the Route 66 kitsch, clean conical concrete cabins, and 1950s cars in the parking lot. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-003 |
Guest-reported drawbackbathroomreviewer: Kelley F |
Guests found the shower miniature and the tiles filthy or very worn. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-004 |
Guest-reported drawbackamenitiesreviewer: Molly H |
Guests noted the lack of coffee in the room or lobby as a drawback. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-005 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Butterfield Stage Co Steak Housedining |
Butterfield Stage Co Steak House is a nearby restaurant located a short distance from the hotel. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-006 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Navajo County Historical Museumattractions |
Navajo County Historical Museum is a nearby attraction within walking distance of the hotel. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-007 |
Walkability or transportationaccess |
A car is recommended for getting to the hotel, and the walkability grade is 38 out of 100. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-2-001 |
Guest-reported strengthatmospherereviewer: Melissa |
The reviewer found the motel to be a fun and unique place to stay. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-002 |
Guest-reported strengthcleanlinessreviewer: Melissa |
The reviewer noted the rooms were clean. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-003 |
Guest-reported strengthpricingtime-sensitive; reviewer: Melissa |
The reviewer found the price to be very affordable. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-004 |
Guest-reported drawbackamenitiesreviewer: Melissa |
The reviewer disliked the lack of amenities such as a pool, hot tub, or breakfast. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-005 |
Guest-reported drawbackroom_equipmentreviewer: Melissa |
The reviewer noted the absence of a hairdryer and coffee maker in the room. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-006 |
Guest-reported drawbackconnectivityreviewer: Melissa |
The reviewer complained that the Wi-Fi connection was unreliable. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-007 |
Guest-reported drawbackroom_sizereviewer: Melissa |
The reviewer found the bathrooms to be very small. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-008 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Petrified Forest National Parkattractions |
Petrified Forest National Park is listed as a nearby attraction. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-009 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Meteor Craterattractions |
Meteor Crater is listed as a nearby attraction. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-010 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Standin’ on the Corner Parkattractions |
Standin’ on the Corner Park is listed as a nearby attraction. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-011 |
Walkability or transportationparking |
Guests can park their vehicles directly outside their wigwam unit. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-012 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationnoise |
A loud train runs every hour near the motel. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-013 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaccessibility |
The wigwams are not wheelchair accessible due to door size constraints. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-014 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpet_policytime-sensitive |
Pets are allowed at the motel for a fee of $25. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-015 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationstaffing |
The motel is a family-owned business with no front desk staff after hours. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-016 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The motel is located at 811 W Hopi Dr in Holbrook, AZ. |
|
independent-editorial:thebrutallyhonesttraveler.comGUEST-2 |
GUEST-3-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_typereviewer: Paula G |
Guests stay in concrete teepee rooms located along Route 66. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaddress |
The motel is located at 811 W Hopi Dr, Holbrook, AZ 86025. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpricingtime-sensitive |
The price for a room with two double beds is $105. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpricingtime-sensitive |
The price for a room with one queen bed is $99. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationparkingreviewer: Paula G |
Cars are parked directly in front of the wigwams, facilitating luggage transport. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenitiesreviewer: Paula G |
The rooms are small, round, and contain only necessary items like beds, a desk, and a TV. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-007 |
Guest-reported drawbacktemperaturereviewer: Paula G |
The concrete construction of the rooms makes them feel cold, particularly the floors. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-008 |
Guest-reported strengthcleanlinessreviewer: Paula G |
The guest found the room clean and sufficient for their needs despite being ascetic. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-009 |
Guest-reported strengthwifireviewer: Paula G |
The guest was pleased that the Wi-Fi was working correctly, contrary to previous reviews. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-010 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: vintage carsattractionreviewer: Paula G |
Vintage cars are parked in front of the teepees, attracting photographers. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-011 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: old Texaco stationreceptionreviewer: Paula G |
The reception area is built into an old Texaco station and includes a small museum. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-012 |
Guest-reported drawbackbookingtime-sensitive; reviewer: Paula G |
The guest found the reservation process difficult due to lack of online booking and limited reception hours. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-013 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationreception_hourstime-sensitive; reviewer: Paula G |
The reception desk was only open from 3 p.m. to 9 p.m. during the guest's stay. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-014 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Petrified Forest National Parknational_parkreviewer: Paula G |
Petrified Forest National Park is located approximately 20 minutes away from the motel. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-015 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Meteor Craterattractionsreviewer: Paula G |
Meteor Crater and Walnut Canyon National Monument are suggested as stops along Route 66. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-016 |
Guest-reported strengthphotographyreviewer: Marielle |
A commenter noted that the motel is a popular photography destination. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-017 |
Guest-reported drawbackcustomer_servicetime-sensitive; reviewer: Umiko |
A commenter criticized the customer service regarding email replies and health protocols. |
|
independent-editorial:paulagaston.comGUEST-3 |
7. Gaylord Opryland Resort & Convention Center
- Class:
destination_resort - Address: 2800 Opryland Drive, Nashville, TN 37214, United States
- Accepted claims: 52
- Score status:
not_scored; covered 74.0 of 100.0 applicable rubric weight - Guest source families: independent-editorial:globaltravelerusa.com, tripadvisor, us-news
- Ledger SHA-256:
55a690980aa49c9872c3a2c75e10554d88fb9c516314ae5905dd14beb616ced6
Criterion result and what it required
| Criterion | Evidence it looked for | Result | Still missing |
|---|---|---|---|
Valuevalue |
broad $–$$$$ price band; verified strengths and inclusions; material guest-review drawbacks or explicit statement that review evidence is sparse; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language |
Priceprice |
broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language |
Locationlocation |
verified property coordinates and identity; property-class profile; nearby useful destination or setting context; deterministic travel distances or times when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Walkabilitywalkability |
frozen pedestrian anchors; pedestrian-route distances rather than straight-line distances; material route barriers or safety limitations; useful daily services when applicable | 3/5 scored | — |
Car-free mobilitycar_free_mobility |
destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness | unknown | frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness |
Guest reputation and consistencyguest_reputation_consistency |
quotation-backed positive guest themes; quotation-backed negative guest themes when present; independent guest-review sources when available; contradictions and source sparsity explicitly disclosed | 3/5 scored | — |
Rooms, comfort, and cleanlinessrooms_comfort_cleanliness |
property-specific room facts; quotation-backed guest likes and dislikes when available; source sparsity and contradictions; renovation or condition freshness when available | 3/5 scored | — |
Service and hospitalityservice_hospitality |
quotation-backed guest service evidence when available; source sparsity and contradictions; documented service model appropriate to the property class | 3/5 scored | — |
Amenities and facilitiesamenities_facilities |
frozen property-class expectation profile; class-appropriate core amenity checklist; property-specific operating evidence; condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material | 4/5 scored | — |
On-site diningon_site_dining |
property-class expectation profile; named on-site outlets when offered; meal periods or schedule when material; guest quality or value evidence when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Character, design, and sense of placecharacter_design_sense_of_place |
property-class profile; property-specific identity or design facts; current condition evidence when available; guest atmosphere evidence when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Operational reliability and frictionoperational_reliability_friction |
current class-appropriate operational policies; quotation-backed friction or reliability themes when available; maintenance and facility-availability evidence; contradictions and seasonality when material | 3/5 scored | — |
All 52 accepted evidence claims
| Claim ID | Evidence sought / topic | Supported claim | Exact source wording | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OFFICIAL-1-001 |
Walkability or transportationshuttle_servicetime-sensitive |
The resort offers a complimentary shuttle that stops at Opry Mills Mall, The Inn at Opryland, and the Cascades Canopy. |
|
updates.gaylordhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-002 |
Walkability or transportation: Nashville International Airportairport_distance |
Nashville International Airport is located 8.3 miles from the resort. |
|
updates.gaylordhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationparking_costtime-sensitive |
On-site parking costs $37.00 per day. |
|
updates.gaylordhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-004 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: SoundWaveswaterpark |
SoundWaves is an indoor waterpark available for hotel guests. |
|
updates.gaylordhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-005 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Old Hickory Steakhousesteakhouse |
Old Hickory Steakhouse is a steakhouse on-site that received a Wine Spectator Award of Excellence in 2026. |
|
updates.gaylordhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-006 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Opry Backstage Grillgrill |
Opry Backstage Grill is located across the street from the resort at The Inn at Opryland. |
|
updates.gaylordhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationatrium |
The resort features a nine-acre glass atrium with indoor gardens and animal habitats. |
|
updates.gaylordhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-2-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Relâche Spaspa_recognitiontime-sensitive |
The Relâche Spa was named one of America's Favorite Spas of 2025 by Spas of America. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operation: Relâche Spaspa_discountstime-sensitive |
Tennessee residents receive a 15% discount on spa treatments and retail items from Sunday to Friday, excluding holidays and blackout dates. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-003 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Cascades Indoor Pool & Jacuzzipool_access |
The resort offers one indoor year-round pool and one outdoor seasonal pool for guest use. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-004 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Cascades Indoor Pool & Jacuzzifitness_classestime-sensitive |
Daily morning yoga classes are held at 7 a.m. by the Cascades indoor pool. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-005 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Gaylord Springs Golf Linksgolf_course |
Gaylord Springs Golf Links is an 18-hole, par-72 Scottish links-style course located on the banks of the Cumberland River. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-006 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Relâche Boutiquespa_retail |
The Relâche Boutique, located inside the Relâche Spa, sells natural cleansers, massage oils, and bathrobes. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-3-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpayment_policy |
The resort is cashless throughout the guest experience. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationdining_policy |
Parties of six or more are automatically assessed a 20% gratuity. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-003 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Foundry Fieldhouse Sports Bar & Taproomvenue_capacity |
Foundry Fieldhouse Sports Bar & Taproom is a 707-seat indoor/outdoor venue with 14 televisions and a two-story LED screen. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-004 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Foundry Fieldhouse Sports Bar & Taproombeverage_program |
Foundry Fieldhouse serves a Tennessee Lager crafted exclusively in partnership with Tennessee Brew Works. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-005 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Old Hickory Steakhouseawardstime-sensitive |
Old Hickory Steakhouse is a steakhouse that received Wine Spectator’s 2026 Award of Excellence. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-006 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Ravellocuisine_style |
Ravello is an Italian restaurant featuring house-made pastas in a lush garden setting. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-007 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Cascades American Cafecuisine_style |
Cascades American Cafe serves modern American classics with a southern twist in a dramatic atrium setting. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-008 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Solario Cantinacuisine_style |
Solario Cantina is a Mexican restaurant featuring signature margaritas and a tequila bar. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-009 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: The Falls Bar & Loungelocation |
The Falls Bar & Lounge is a lobby lounge overlooking twin waterfalls. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-010 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Delta Marketplaceservice_type |
Delta Marketplace is a quick-service option serving Starbucks Coffee. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-011 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Conservatory Cafelocation |
Conservatory Cafe is located in the Garden Atrium and serves Starbucks. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-012 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Cocoa Beanlocation |
Cocoa Bean is located in the Cascades Atrium and serves Starbucks coffee. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-013 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Decibelsaccessibility |
Decibels is a 230-seat indoor restaurant accessible only with a SoundWaves wristband. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-014 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: A La Carteroom_service |
A La Carte offers in-room dining with locally inspired menus delivered in sustainable packaging. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-015 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Cinnabon, Auntie Anne’s, Paisano's Pizzaria & Vino, Stax, Bravo Gelato, Carvelquick_service |
The resort offers quick-service options including Cinnabon, Auntie Anne’s, Paisano's Pizzaria & Vino, Stax, Bravo Gelato, and Carvel. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-016 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: General Jackson Showboat Cruisescruises |
General Jackson Showboat Cruises are available as a dining event. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-017 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Gaylord Springs Golf Linksgolf |
Gaylord Springs Golf Links is a location for hosting private events. |
|
www.marriott.comOFFICIAL-3 |
GUEST-1-001 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Grand Ole Oprylocation |
The hotel is located near the Grand Ole Opry and Ryman Auditorium. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-002 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: SoundWavesamenities |
The property features a water park attraction called SoundWaves. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-003 |
Walkability or transportationtransportation |
The hotel is rated as somewhat walkable with a grade of 75 out of 100. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-004 |
Guest-reported drawbackproperty_sizereviewer: ROGER W |
Guests report that the property is large and requires significant walking to move between areas. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-005 |
Guest-reported drawbackpricingtime-sensitive; reviewer: ROGER W |
Guests find the on-site food and room rates to be expensive. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-006 |
Guest-reported strengthamenitiesreviewer: Grace W |
Guests praise the indoor botanical gardens and the overall beauty of the venue. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-007 |
Guest-reported drawback: SoundWavesservicereviewer: Amy K |
Guests report long wait times and limited food availability at the SoundWaves water park. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-2-001 |
Guest-reported strengthroom_comfortreviewer: source_summary |
Guests report that rooms are comfortable and include minifridges, high-speed internet, and atrium views. |
|
us-newsGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-002 |
Guest-reported drawbackpricingreviewer: source_summary |
Guests note that nearly everything within the resort is expensive, especially restaurant fare. |
|
us-newsGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-003 |
Walkability or transportationlocation_distance |
The resort is located about a 10-mile drive from downtown Nashville. |
|
us-newsGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-004 |
Walkability or transportationshuttle_servicetime-sensitive |
A daily shuttle takes guests to and from the airport and to central attractions downtown for an additional fee. |
|
us-newsGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-005 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Gaylord Springs Golf Linksgolf |
The resort features an 18-hole golf course named Gaylord Springs Golf Links. |
|
us-newsGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-006 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Old Hickory Steakhousedining_options |
The resort offers 17 on-site dining options including the Old Hickory Steakhouse. |
|
us-newsGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpool_facilities |
The resort has three pools, including the Cascades Pool and Magnolia Pool. |
|
us-newsGUEST-2 |
GUEST-3-001 |
Guest-reported strengthcheck_in_experiencereviewer: Kimberly Inlander |
The reviewer found the valet and check-in process smooth after initially getting turned around in the complex. |
|
independent-editorial:globaltravelerusa.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-002 |
Guest-reported drawbackroom_noisereviewer: Kimberly Inlander |
The reviewer noted that live music at the bar in the Cascades atrium can make the guestroom loud. |
|
independent-editorial:globaltravelerusa.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-003 |
Guest-reported strengthroom_sizereviewer: Kimberly Inlander |
The reviewer praised the spacious size of the guestroom and the separate sink alcove. |
|
independent-editorial:globaltravelerusa.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-004 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: SoundWaveswaterparkreviewer: Kimberly Inlander |
The resort features an on-site 4-acre indoor and outdoor waterpark called SoundWaves. |
|
independent-editorial:globaltravelerusa.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-005 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Delta Riverboat Ridesriverboat_tourreviewer: Kimberly Inlander |
Guests can take Delta Riverboat Rides through the resort's indoor gardens with a tour guide. |
|
independent-editorial:globaltravelerusa.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-006 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Cascades American Cafe, Fuse Sports Bar, Solario Cantinarestaurantsreviewer: Kimberly Inlander |
The resort offers dining options including Cascades American Cafe, Fuse Sports Bar, and Solario Cantina. |
|
independent-editorial:globaltravelerusa.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationevent_spacetime-sensitive |
The hotel offers more than 760,000 square feet of event space across 90 rooms. |
|
independent-editorial:globaltravelerusa.comGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-008 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationexpansiontime-sensitive |
The resort announced a $131 million expansion with planned completion in spring 2027. |
|
independent-editorial:globaltravelerusa.comGUEST-3 |
8. Days Inn by Wyndham Hillsdale
- Class:
ordinary_chain - Address: 3241 West Carleton Road, Hillsdale, MI 49242, United States
- Accepted claims: 38
- Score status:
not_scored; covered 69.0 of 100.0 applicable rubric weight - Guest source families: expedia-group, kayak, tripadvisor
- Ledger SHA-256:
414ed2daf0bdff08503f813ba97a6fca1616be161dc9e590f7f9ad4b2dacc98b
Criterion result and what it required
| Criterion | Evidence it looked for | Result | Still missing |
|---|---|---|---|
Valuevalue |
broad $–$$$$ price band; verified strengths and inclusions; material guest-review drawbacks or explicit statement that review evidence is sparse; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Priceprice |
broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Locationlocation |
verified property coordinates and identity; property-class profile; nearby useful destination or setting context; deterministic travel distances or times when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Walkabilitywalkability |
frozen pedestrian anchors; pedestrian-route distances rather than straight-line distances; material route barriers or safety limitations; useful daily services when applicable | 2/5 scored | — |
Car-free mobilitycar_free_mobility |
destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness | unknown | destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness |
Guest reputation and consistencyguest_reputation_consistency |
quotation-backed positive guest themes; quotation-backed negative guest themes when present; independent guest-review sources when available; contradictions and source sparsity explicitly disclosed | 2/5 scored | — |
Rooms, comfort, and cleanlinessrooms_comfort_cleanliness |
property-specific room facts; quotation-backed guest likes and dislikes when available; source sparsity and contradictions; renovation or condition freshness when available | 2/5 scored | — |
Service and hospitalityservice_hospitality |
quotation-backed guest service evidence when available; source sparsity and contradictions; documented service model appropriate to the property class | 2/5 scored | — |
Amenities and facilitiesamenities_facilities |
frozen property-class expectation profile; class-appropriate core amenity checklist; property-specific operating evidence; condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material | 3/5 scored | — |
On-site diningon_site_dining |
property-class expectation profile; named on-site outlets when offered; meal periods or schedule when material; guest quality or value evidence when available | 2/5 scored | — |
Character, design, and sense of placecharacter_design_sense_of_place |
property-class profile; property-specific identity or design facts; current condition evidence when available; guest atmosphere evidence when available | unknown | property-specific identity or design facts; current condition evidence when available; guest atmosphere evidence when available |
Operational reliability and frictionoperational_reliability_friction |
current class-appropriate operational policies; quotation-backed friction or reliability themes when available; maintenance and facility-availability evidence; contradictions and seasonality when material | 1/5 scored | — |
All 38 accepted evidence claims
| Claim ID | Evidence sought / topic | Supported claim | Exact source wording | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OFFICIAL-1-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationbreakfast |
The hotel offers a free light breakfast item and coffee or tea. |
|
www.wyndhamhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpool |
The hotel features a heated indoor pool. |
|
www.wyndhamhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-003 |
Guest-reported drawbackroom_amenitiesreviewer: Blue Rewards Member | Michigan, United States |
A guest reported the hotel was bare bones with no in-room coffeemaker or lobby coffee outside of breakfast. |
|
www.wyndhamhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-004 |
Guest-reported drawbackservicereviewer: Blue Rewards Member | Michigan, United States |
A guest complained that the front desk staff was not helpful and failed to provide check-in information. |
|
www.wyndhamhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-005 |
Guest-reported drawbackcleanlinessreviewer: Blue Rewards Member | Michigan, United States |
A guest reported severe cleanliness issues including dirty floors and bugs in the room. |
|
www.wyndhamhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-006 |
Guest-reported strengthservicereviewer: Blue Rewards Member | Michigan, United States |
A guest praised the staff for being helpful during a power outage. |
|
www.wyndhamhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-007 |
Guest-reported strengthcleanliness_poolreviewer: Blue Rewards Member | Michigan, United States |
A guest stated the hotel was clean and the pool was amazing. |
|
www.wyndhamhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-008 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Hillsdale Lanesbowling |
The hotel is located near Hillsdale Lanes for bowling. |
|
www.wyndhamhotels.comOFFICIAL-1 |
GUEST-1-001 |
Guest-reported strengthstaff_and_conditionreviewer: source_summary |
Guests generally praise the helpful staff and overall property condition. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-002 |
Guest-reported drawbackbreakfast_qualityreviewer: Verified review May 19, 2026 |
A guest reported that the breakfast was bad due to short staffing. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-003 |
Guest-reported drawbackfood_and_smellreviewer: Verified review Mar 1, 2026 |
A guest complained about terrible food, a broken coffee machine, and a strong smell of marijuana in the hallway. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-004 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Hillsdale Collegenearby_landmark |
Hillsdale College is located 2.2 km away, a 2-minute drive from the hotel. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-005 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Baw Beese Lakenearby_nature |
Baw Beese Lake is located 7.4 km away, a 7-minute drive from the hotel. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-006 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Free on-the-go breakfastbreakfast_servicetime-sensitive |
The hotel offers a free on-the-go breakfast from 6:00 AM to 10:00 AM. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpool_hourstime-sensitive |
Pool access is available from 9:00 AM to 10:00 PM. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-1 |
GUEST-2-001 |
Walkability or transportation: Hillsdale Collegedistance_to_college |
The hotel is located two miles from Hillsdale College. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-002 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Skating Rinkskating_rink |
A skating rink is located directly across the street from the hotel. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpool_amenities |
The hotel features an indoor heated pool and a hot tub. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-004 |
Guest-reported drawbackaccessibility_cleanlinessreviewer: Adventurer275917 |
Guest Adventurer275917 noted that the hotel has no elevator and the stairwells were dirty. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-005 |
Guest-reported drawbackoverbookingreviewer: Mandi V |
Guest Mandi V reported that the hotel was overbooked and gave away their reserved room. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-2 |
GUEST-3-001 |
Guest-reported strengthlocationreviewer: source_summary |
Guests consistently praised the hotel's convenient location. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-002 |
Guest-reported strengthbedsreviewer: source_summary |
Guests found the beds comfortable. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-003 |
Guest-reported drawbackcleanlinessreviewer: source_summary |
Some guests reported issues with odors or dirty carpets in their rooms. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-004 |
Guest-reported drawbacktvreviewer: source_summary |
There were repeated complaints about broken or malfunctioning TVs. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-005 |
Guest-reported drawbacktvreviewer: Danielle |
Danielle reported that the TV in her booked king room was broken and she was switched to a queen room. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-006 |
Guest-reported drawbackcleanlinessreviewer: Harlan |
Harlan noted that the room had a smell and the carpet felt damp. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-007 |
Guest-reported drawbacktvreviewer: Daniel |
Daniel reported that the TV did not work during his stay and requests for help were ignored. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-008 |
Guest-reported strengthroom_conditionreviewer: Melissa |
Melissa found the room spacious, clean, and newly renovated with working appliances. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-009 |
Guest-reported drawbackroom_environmentreviewer: Melissa |
Melissa complained about loud hallway noise, light leakage around the window, and very firm beds. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-010 |
Guest-reported drawbackroom_conditionreviewer: Verified Hotel Guest |
A verified hotel guest reported that the mattress and pillows were very old and the TV was glitchy. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-011 |
Guest-reported drawbackbookingreviewer: Amanda |
Amanda reported being turned away due to overbooking despite prepaying for three nights. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-012 |
Guest-reported drawbackamenitiestime-sensitive; reviewer: Verified Hotel Guest |
A verified hotel guest noted that the hot tub had been broken for over a month. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-013 |
Guest-reported strengthamenitiestime-sensitive; reviewer: James |
James reported that the exercise room and pool were fixed and operational. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-014 |
Guest-reported drawbackamenitiestime-sensitive; reviewer: Gary |
Gary complained that the hotel did not inform guests that the pool and spa were closed. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-015 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel offers an indoor pool, fitness center, and meeting room. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-016 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationservices |
The hotel provides free on-the-go breakfast, free WiFi in public areas, and free self parking. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-017 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Will Carleton Poor House Museumattractions |
The Will Carleton Poor House Museum is located 2.3 miles from the hotel. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
GUEST-3-018 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Grace Episcopal Churchattractions |
The Grace Episcopal Church is located 2.8 miles from the hotel. |
|
kayakGUEST-3 |
9. The Inn at Stonington
- Class:
small_inn_bnb - Address: 60 Water Street, Stonington, CT 06378, United States
- Accepted claims: 51
- Score status:
not_scored; covered 74.0 of 100.0 applicable rubric weight - Guest source families: expedia-group, tripadvisor
- Ledger SHA-256:
4574c3ab9a27b128ef1b67acd510b4c202fedc8fa4cdf04a1ba70180ef08411e
Criterion result and what it required
| Criterion | Evidence it looked for | Result | Still missing |
|---|---|---|---|
Valuevalue |
broad $–$$$$ price band; verified strengths and inclusions; material guest-review drawbacks or explicit statement that review evidence is sparse; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Priceprice |
broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Locationlocation |
verified property coordinates and identity; property-class profile; nearby useful destination or setting context; deterministic travel distances or times when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Walkabilitywalkability |
frozen pedestrian anchors; pedestrian-route distances rather than straight-line distances; material route barriers or safety limitations; useful daily services when applicable | 4/5 scored | — |
Car-free mobilitycar_free_mobility |
destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness | unknown | destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness |
Guest reputation and consistencyguest_reputation_consistency |
quotation-backed positive guest themes; quotation-backed negative guest themes when present; independent guest-review sources when available; contradictions and source sparsity explicitly disclosed | 3/5 scored | — |
Rooms, comfort, and cleanlinessrooms_comfort_cleanliness |
property-specific room facts; quotation-backed guest likes and dislikes when available; source sparsity and contradictions; renovation or condition freshness when available | 3/5 scored | — |
Service and hospitalityservice_hospitality |
quotation-backed guest service evidence when available; source sparsity and contradictions; documented service model appropriate to the property class | 3/5 scored | — |
Amenities and facilitiesamenities_facilities |
frozen property-class expectation profile; class-appropriate core amenity checklist; property-specific operating evidence; condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material | 3/5 scored | — |
On-site diningon_site_dining |
property-class expectation profile; named on-site outlets when offered; meal periods or schedule when material; guest quality or value evidence when available | 3/5 scored | — |
Character, design, and sense of placecharacter_design_sense_of_place |
property-class profile; property-specific identity or design facts; current condition evidence when available; guest atmosphere evidence when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Operational reliability and frictionoperational_reliability_friction |
current class-appropriate operational policies; quotation-backed friction or reliability themes when available; maintenance and facility-availability evidence; contradictions and seasonality when material | 3/5 scored | — |
All 51 accepted evidence claims
| Claim ID | Evidence sought / topic | Supported claim | Exact source wording | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OFFICIAL-1-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_count |
The Inn at Stonington has 18 rooms. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The hotel is located in Stonington Borough, Connecticut. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The hotel is situated along the waterfront of Stonington, CT harbor. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-004 |
Walkability or transportationwalkability |
The hotel is a short walking distance from restaurants, shops, and galleries. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
Guest rooms feature gas fireplaces. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
Guest rooms feature soaking tubs. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-007 |
Guest-reported strengthroom_amenitiesreviewer: Yankee Magazine |
Yankee Magazine describes the hotel as having in-room gas fireplaces and soaking tubs. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-008 |
Walkability or transportationwalkabilityreviewer: Rhode Island Monthly |
Rhode Island Monthly states the hotel is in walking distance of shops, galleries, and eateries. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-009 |
Guest-reported strengthaestheticsreviewer: Connecticut Magazine |
Connecticut Magazine describes the hotel's aesthetic as similar to Nantucket. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-2-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_count |
The Inn at Stonington has eighteen guest rooms. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-002 |
Guest-reported strengthroom_amenitiesreviewer: Yankee Magazine |
Guests can enjoy in-room gas fireplaces. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-003 |
Guest-reported strengthroom_amenitiesreviewer: Yankee Magazine |
Guests can enjoy in-room soaking tubs. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocationreviewer: Rhode Island Monthly |
The hotel is located on the waterfront. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-005 |
Walkability or transportationaccessibilityreviewer: Rhode Island Monthly |
The hotel is within walking distance of local shops. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-006 |
Walkability or transportationaccessibilityreviewer: Rhode Island Monthly |
The hotel is within walking distance of local galleries. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-007 |
Walkability or transportationaccessibilityreviewer: Rhode Island Monthly |
The hotel is within walking distance of local eateries. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-2-008 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationaestheticreviewer: Connecticut Magazine |
The hotel is described as having a Nantucket-like aesthetic. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-2 |
OFFICIAL-3-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_amenities |
All guest rooms except room 15 feature gas fireplaces. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationbathroom_features |
Most bathrooms include large soaking tubs and separate walk-in showers. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_count |
The inn has 18 unique guest rooms designed for an intimate environment. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationroom_views |
Seaside rooms offer views of Stonington Harbor and Fishers Island Sound. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The inn is located in Stonington Borough, Connecticut, along the waterfront. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-006 |
Walkability or transportationproximity |
The inn is a short walk from award-winning restaurants, shops, and galleries. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-007 |
Guest-reported strengthatmospherereviewer: Yankee Magazine |
Yankee Magazine describes the inn as a place to draw calm from in-room fireplaces and soaking tubs. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-008 |
Walkability or transportationaccessibilityreviewer: Rhode Island Monthly |
Rhode Island Monthly states the inn is in walking distance of shops, galleries, and eateries. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-3 |
OFFICIAL-3-009 |
Guest-reported strengthaestheticreviewer: Connecticut Magazine |
Connecticut Magazine compares the inn to a piece of Nantucket. |
|
innatstonington.comOFFICIAL-3 |
GUEST-1-001 |
Walkability or transportation: Stonington Old Lighthouse Museumdistance_to_attraction |
The hotel is located a 5-minute walk from the Stonington Old Lighthouse Museum. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationbreakfast_inclusion |
The hotel provides a complimentary continental breakfast. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationevening_amenity |
Guests receive nightly wine and cheese as a complimentary amenity. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationfitness_facility |
The hotel offers a fitness center. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocationreviewer: MayLehmannNYC |
The hotel is situated near the end of Water Street. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationcheck_in_policyreviewer: albie02 |
The hotel offers a 2 PM check-in time. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-007 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Mystic Seaportdistance_to_attraction |
The hotel is 5 miles from Mystic Seaport. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-2-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationproperty_type |
The property is an adults-only guesthouse. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The hotel offers a 24-hour fitness center. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-003 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Kayakingactivities |
Kayaking is available on-site at the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationoutdoor_spaces |
The property includes a terrace and a garden. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-005 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Free daily receptionfood_drink |
The property offers a free daily reception. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-006 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Coffee/tea in a common areafood_drink |
The property offers coffee and tea in a common area. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-007 |
Walkability or transportation: James Merrill Housenearby_landmarks |
James Merrill House is a 3-minute walk from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-008 |
Walkability or transportation: Stonington's Old Lighthouse Museumnearby_landmarks |
Stonington's Old Lighthouse Museum is a 6-minute walk from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-009 |
Walkability or transportation: Dubois Beachnearby_landmarks |
Dubois Beach is a 6-minute walk from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-010 |
Walkability or transportation: Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Explorationnearby_landmarks |
Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration is an 11-minute drive from the property. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-011 |
Guest-reported strengthdiningreviewer: Verified review Mar 29, 2026 |
A guest praised the daily evening wine and cheese reception and breakfasts. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-012 |
Guest-reported strengthroom_featuresreviewer: Verified review Apr 10, 2026 |
A guest appreciated the ocean view and fireplace in their room. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-013 |
Guest-reported drawbackdiningreviewer: Verified review May 24, 2017 |
A guest disliked that the included breakfast was continental rather than hot. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-014 |
Guest-reported drawbackroom_amenitiesreviewer: Verified review Jun 13, 2021 |
A guest complained about the lack of a fridge in the room. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-015 |
Guest-reported drawback: Breakwater restaurantparkingreviewer: Verified review Jun 13, 2021 |
A guest complained that the shared parking lot with Breakwater restaurant was difficult to manage due to stolen spots. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-016 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: Noahslocal_diningreviewer: Verified review Sep 6, 2018 |
A guest recommended Noahs for breakfast or dinner. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-017 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Dog Watch cafelocal_diningreviewer: Verified review Sep 4, 2018 |
A guest enjoyed visiting the Dog Watch cafe. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-018 |
Guest-reported drawbacklocal_activitiesreviewer: Verified review Sep 6, 2018 |
A guest noted there was little to do in the evening around town except dinner. |
|
expedia-groupGUEST-2 |
10. Blue Swallow Motel
- Class:
independent_motel - Address: 815 East Route 66 Boulevard, Tucumcari, NM 88401, United States
- Accepted claims: 18
- Score status:
not_scored; covered 33.0 of 95.0 applicable rubric weight - Guest source families: agoda, tripadvisor
- Ledger SHA-256:
6ef48e976b57d1fcf961bcb1266e8383b164012b15f096000110fabb3b649edb
Criterion result and what it required
| Criterion | Evidence it looked for | Result | Still missing |
|---|---|---|---|
Valuevalue |
broad $–$$$$ price band; verified strengths and inclusions; material guest-review drawbacks or explicit statement that review evidence is sparse; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Priceprice |
broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band; property-class profile | unknown | broad $–$$$$ price band from current public positioning or consistent guest value language; basis note identifying the source of the band |
Locationlocation |
verified property coordinates and identity; property-class profile; nearby useful destination or setting context; deterministic travel distances or times when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Walkabilitywalkability |
frozen pedestrian anchors; pedestrian-route distances rather than straight-line distances; material route barriers or safety limitations; useful daily services when applicable | 3/5 scored | — |
Car-free mobilitycar_free_mobility |
destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness | unknown | destinations served; frequency or expected wait; operating hours and season; transfer burden; cost or inclusion; luggage and mobility-accessibility usefulness |
Guest reputation and consistencyguest_reputation_consistency |
quotation-backed positive guest themes; quotation-backed negative guest themes when present; independent guest-review sources when available; contradictions and source sparsity explicitly disclosed | 4/5 scored | — |
Rooms, comfort, and cleanlinessrooms_comfort_cleanliness |
property-specific room facts; quotation-backed guest likes and dislikes when available; source sparsity and contradictions; renovation or condition freshness when available | unknown | property-specific room facts; renovation or condition freshness when available |
Service and hospitalityservice_hospitality |
quotation-backed guest service evidence when available; source sparsity and contradictions; documented service model appropriate to the property class | unknown | documented service model appropriate to the property class |
Amenities and facilitiesamenities_facilities |
frozen property-class expectation profile; class-appropriate core amenity checklist; property-specific operating evidence; condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material | unknown | condition, restrictions, and seasonality when material |
On-site diningon_site_dining |
property-class expectation profile; named on-site outlets when offered; meal periods or schedule when material; guest quality or value evidence when available | not_applicable | — |
Character, design, and sense of placecharacter_design_sense_of_place |
property-class profile; property-specific identity or design facts; current condition evidence when available; guest atmosphere evidence when available | 4/5 scored | — |
Operational reliability and frictionoperational_reliability_friction |
current class-appropriate operational policies; quotation-backed friction or reliability themes when available; maintenance and facility-availability evidence; contradictions and seasonality when material | unknown | current class-appropriate operational policies; quotation-backed friction or reliability themes when available; maintenance and facility-availability evidence |
All 18 accepted evidence claims
| Claim ID | Evidence sought / topic | Supported claim | Exact source wording | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
OFFICIAL-1-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationlocation |
The motel is located at 815 E. Rte. 66 Blvd. in Tucumcari, New Mexico. |
|
blueswallowmotel.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-002 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationhistory |
The Blue Swallow Motel has been operating since 1939. |
|
blueswallowmotel.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-003 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationownership |
The property is family owned and operated by owners Robert and Dawn. |
|
blueswallowmotel.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The motel features distinctive attached garages for guests. |
|
blueswallowmotel.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-005 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The motel displays a neon light installation every night. |
|
blueswallowmotel.comOFFICIAL-1 |
OFFICIAL-1-006 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The motel includes a historic courtyard area. |
|
blueswallowmotel.comOFFICIAL-1 |
GUEST-1-001 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationhistory |
The Blue Swallow Motel is a classic Motor Court established in 1939 on historic Route 66. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-002 |
Guest-reported strengthrooms_atmospherereviewer: source_summary |
Guests appreciate the clean, well-maintained rooms and the nostalgic atmosphere. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-003 |
Guest-reported drawbackamenitiesreviewer: source_summary |
Some guests mention limited in-room amenities. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-004 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationamenities |
The motel offers free parking and free high-speed internet. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-1-005 |
Walkability or transportationaccessibility |
The motel is rated as somewhat walkable with a grade of 64 out of 100. |
|
tripadvisorGUEST-1 |
GUEST-2-001 |
Guest-reported strengthguest_reviewreviewer: Stan from United States |
Guest Stan from United States described the property as the best motel in Tucumcari and highly historic. |
|
agodaGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-002 |
Guest-reported strengthservicereviewer: Dale from United States |
Guest Dale from United States praised the owners and the friendliness of fellow travelers. |
|
agodaGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-003 |
Walkability or transportationtransport |
The property offers a shuttle service for guests. |
|
agodaGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-004 |
Named dining outlet or dining program: BBQ facilitiesdining |
The property features on-site BBQ facilities for guests to cook their own meals. |
|
agodaGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-005 |
Named on-property or nearby activity: Mesalands Community College's Dinosaur Museumattractions |
The Mesalands Community College's Dinosaur Museum is located 710 meters from the property. |
|
agodaGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-006 |
Walkability or transportation: Tucumcari Municipal Airportaccess |
Tucumcari Municipal Airport is located a 7-minute drive from the motel. |
|
agodaGUEST-2 |
GUEST-2-007 |
Property fact, amenity, or operationpricingtime-sensitive |
The property has an average room price of $123. |
|
agodaGUEST-2 |
Cross-hotel findings
- generalization: All five property classes produced two valid lineages with literal, subject-isolated evidence and class guest-source quotas met.
- sparse-preservation: All ten scorecards validly remained not_scored; weighted coverage ranged from 34.7% to 74.0% rather than converting unknowns to zero.
- price-value-acquisition: Price and value remained unknown for 10 of 10 hotels, indicating a general acquisition/normalization gap rather than class-specific sparsity.
- car-free-mobility: Car-free mobility remained unknown for 10 of 10 hotels because operational details such as destinations, frequency, hours, cost, and luggage/accessibility utility were not established.
- extraction-reliability: Step 2 required 30 retries across 82 calls (36.6%); rejected attempts remained preserved and no invalid row entered a final ledger.
- scoring-reliability: Step 3 used 60 calls, 2 retries, and 8 fail-closed demotions; all final scorecards validated with zero cloud calls.
- location-identity: Nine subjects had complete location intelligence; Wigwam safely preserved a blocked identity-resolution gap without contaminating scoring evidence.
- mac-qwen38: Mac-local qwen3.8:27b-mlx passed one constrained transport/quotation canary but failed repeatability and semantic/schema reliability; production packets remained on the qualified remote route.
- publication: No publication stage was inferred or run from Steps 1–3.
Verification and reproducibility
- Cohort summary SHA-256:
625f116457310959a73da6889ddd0f521cc92d69e7c28024b0f44556da4245d4 - Cross-hotel verification SHA-256:
ff416f0ff3a83d74c28ddc7c521aee3e92eb2cfa9ac1d57e405cae554674d293 - Generalization findings SHA-256:
7af28474dcd77a092cb6d597a044fa227cff461a766c84e2e706f7e04e1648ea - Frozen rubric SHA-256:
ca4c6c3b1290f8ac075e6456cc97243c4fbaafb37c1ca098abecdc4e4f8a0d41
Every accepted quotation was independently checked against its retained, hashed source text. Every claim carried the expected hotel subject and allowlisted source ID. The final cross-hotel verification reported zero errors.
Public report content marker: 385d116182655883a5b97c54cd93ed1f487d23cc6fbb2f7090e6f5cecad1362c
